In 1843, Missouri attempted to extradite Joseph Smith, the founder of Mormonism, for allegedly attempting to assassinate Missouri Governor Lilburn Boggs. He escaped arrest with the help of members of his church and was released on habeas corpus by the Nauvoo City Court, of which he was mayor, although this was outside the court`s jurisdiction. Residents of nearby Carthage, Illinois, felt Smith was abusing his position to avoid arrest. They asked Governor Ford to call the militia to arrest Smith, which Governor Ford refused. [10]:139 A group of former Mormons published an article entitled Nauvoo Expositor, detailing Smith`s alleged abuse of power. Together with the Nauvoo City Council, Smith ordered the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor. This caused an uproar in nearby towns, which interpreted the order as an attack on freedom of expression. Smith was accused of provoking a riot, which the Nauvoo courts rejected. Nearby towns raised money for a militia to capture Smith. Governor Ford arrived in Carthage and sent Smith the message that Ford would call the militia if he did not surrender.[11] On June 18, Smith declared martial law[12] in Nauvoo and proclaimed the Nauvoo Legion, an organized urban militia of about 5,000 men,[13] to protect Nauvoo from outside violence.
Ford sent a group of men and abolished martial law.[12] By this time, Smith had fled to Iowa, but his supporters persuaded him to return. He was arrested for treason against the state of Illinois for declaring martial law. [11] While awaiting trial in Carthage prison, Smith was murdered by a mob. In 1845, Nauvoo was stripped of its charter for abuse of power. This led to a series of conflicts known as the Illinois Mormon War. [14] It is difficult to say what national martial law would look like in the United States. Today, because it`s not something that happened for a long, long time. One case dates back to 1941. After the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Governor Joseph B. Poindexter, with the approval of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, ordered martial law to be imposed on Hawaii, which was still a territory, so that the army would have a free hand to fortify the island of Oahu against a feared Japanese invasion.
In addition, FDR might have feared a revolt of Hawaii`s 150,000 Japanese Americans, who made up 35 percent of the population, according to this 2017 Stars and Stripes article. But Robert M. Chesney, a professor and associate dean at the University of Texas School of Law and co-founder of the Lawfare blog, warned in a March email that if an emergency required military intervention in the United States, there was also a danger that even a short-term military takeover could cause lasting damage to democracy. Martial law has long been mired in confusion in the United States, but that hasn`t always stopped state and federal officials from explaining it. In fact, the Brennan Center has identified 68 declarations of martial law in U.S. history. Our research on these events is presented in the appendix below. It accompanies our report on martial law, which examines the history of the concept and the legal principles that govern it. Throughout U.S. history, federal and state officials have declared martial law at least 68 times, according to Joseph Nunn, an expert at the Brennan Center for Justice. “One of the most important things to remember about the insurrection law is that it`s not martial law,” Banks said.
“The purpose of using the mechanisms of the insurrection law is to enforce the law, not replace it.” Apart from these general principles, there are many questions that are simply impossible to answer given the rare and confusing precedents. In addition, while the president does not have the power to replace civilian agencies with federal troops, he has sufficient authority under current law to deploy troops in support of civil law enforcement. Until Congress and state legislatures pass stricter, more defined limits, the exact scope of martial law will remain unclear, and the president`s ability to order standing troops without martial law will be dangerously broad. In American law, martial law is limited by several court decisions rendered between the American Civil War and World War II. In 1878, Congress passed the Posse Comitatus Act, which prohibits the involvement of the U.S. military in domestic law enforcement without congressional approval. Usually, but not always, the term “martial law” refers to the third category. It describes a power that, in an emergency, allows the military to set aside civilian authorities and exercise jurisdiction over the population of a given area.
Comments are closed.